The trouble with better match graphics is that if you computer is not high spec it is bound to impact on the time it takes to play the game, personally I like it as it is now as you can easily imagine the players' moves etc and the joy of a screamer from 30 yards is just as good, no matter the graphics. Also for some reason if the graphics were as good as FIFA for example (not saying that is what you are asking for) then to me it would feel more like an arcade game than a management sim.
Another idea I have is that you can choose the scout to compare the scouted player against any of your team in the same position, rather than your strongest player every time. It is often the fringe players or second striker you want to compare your scouted player against not your strongest one anyway ! | 
